Solo 401K vs. Self Directed IRA: What’s Best For You?

Bullion Baron

Disclaimer: I may receive affiliate commissions for recommending certain products or services, but this does not affect my opinion of them.  Please do your research before investing in any of the companies mentioned, as I have done my best to give you the top-rated companies I've researched.

Are you seeking ways to secure your financial future and have the retirement life you deserve? Solo 401 k and Self-directed IRA options that you can explore. Investing your retirement funds in precious metals like gold and silver is a good way to plan your future and ensure that you live your dream retirement life. Not only will you be able to protect your wealth from the diminishing effects of inflation and recession, but you will also appreciably grow your investment over time. However, you must understand that the precious metals company that you invest with largely determines the success or otherwise of your investment. And having researched the top companies today, Augusta Precious Metals is my #1 recommendation for gold and other precious metals investment.

  • Money magazine’s “Best Overall” Gold IRA Company in 2022
  • Quarterback Joe Montana and his financial team chose Augusta
  • Zero fees for up to 10 years — every customer qualifies
  • Investopedia’s “Most Transparent” Gold IRA Company in 2022
  • Free guides on how to avoid gimmicks & high-pressure tactics used by gold IRA companies

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Investors looking to diversify their investment portfolios with precious metals have a choice between two popular retirement savings vehicles: the solo 401k and the self-directed IRA. While both are viable options, there are key differences in terms of eligibility requirements, tax benefits, fees, and investment restrictions that must be considered before deciding which option is perfect for you. In this article, we'll take an in-depth look at the solo 401k vs self-directed IRA so you can make a conscious decision about your own financial future.

Comparison of Solo 401k and Self-Directed IRA

Investment Options & Flexibility

Both Solo 401k and Self-Directed IRAs offer investors the ability to invest in a wide spectrum of assets, including stocks, bonds, mutual funds, ETFs, Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs), private placements, and more. However, with a Solo 401k, you can also invest in physical precious metals like gold or silver coins or bars. This is not an option with a Self-Directed IRA. Additionally, while both accounts allow for loans against the balance of the account up to certain limits set by law, only the Solo 401k allows for Roth contributions which are taxed differently than traditional contributions.


When it comes to taxes, there are some differences between these two retirement accounts that investors should be aware of before making their decision. With a Solo 401k, all earnings within the account grow tax-deferred until withdrawal at retirement age when they become taxable income; however, this is not true for Roth contributions made into either type of account as those will be taxed upfront, but withdrawals from them, later on, will be tax-free upon reaching retirement age. On the other hand, with a traditional Self-Directed IRA, any gains realized within the account are subject to taxation each year regardless if withdrawn or not. In contrast, with a Solo 401k, no taxes need to be paid until the money is taken out at retirement age.


The fees associated with both types of accounts vary depending on what type of investments you choose and who your custodian/administrator is, but generally speaking, they tend to be similar across providers. It is critical to shop around and compare costs before deciding which one works best for you financially. Generally speaking, most administrators charge an annual fee plus additional charges per transaction, so make sure you understand exactly what fees may apply before investing your hard-earned money into either type of account.

Comparing a Solo 401k and a Self-Directed IRA can help investors understand the differences between these two retirement accounts, allowing them to make an informed decision on which one is best suited for their investment needs. Now let's check out the pros and cons of each option.

Pros and Cons of Solo 401k vs. Self-Directed IRA Investing

Talking about investing in precious metals, there are two main options available: a solo 401k and a self-directed IRA. Both offer distinct advantages and disadvantages that investors should consider before making their decision.

Pros of Solo 401k

A solo 401k allows for higher contribution limits than a traditional IRA or Roth IRA, with up to $57,000 per year (or $63,500 if you’re over 50). Additionally, contributions are tax-deductible, and earnings grow tax-deferred until retirement age. The money can also be used to purchase physical gold or silver coins without any additional taxes or penalties.

Pros of Self-Directed IRA

With a self-directed retirement account, investors have more flexibility when it comes to investment choices, as they can invest in alternative assets such as real estate or private businesses in addition to precious metals. Furthermore, the annual contribution limit is slightly higher at $6,000 ($7,000 if you’re over 50).

Cons of Both Options

One downside of both types of accounts is that they require custodians who charge fees for setting up and managing the account which can add up quickly depending on how often transactions occur. Additionally, both accounts come with early withdrawal penalties if money is taken out prior to retirement age unless certain conditions are met, such as disability or death. Lastly, neither option offers protection from inflation since the value of gold and silver tends to fluctuate significantly over time.

Both solo 401k and self-directed IRA investments offer advantages to investors looking to protect their wealth with precious metals. It is vital to weigh the pros and cons of each option carefully in order to make an informed decision that best fits your individual needs. Now, let's take a look at the conclusion of this topic.

Key Takeaway:

Solo 401k and self-directed IRA offer distinct advantages for investing in precious metals, such as higher contribution limits, tax benefits, and more flexibility. However, both come with custodial fees and early withdrawal penalties that should be considered before making a decision.


When it comes to investing in precious metals with an IRA, investors have two options: a solo 401k or a self-directed IRA. Both of these options offer unique advantages and disadvantages that should be considered before making any investment decisions. A solo 401k offers more flexibility and control over investments than a self-directed IRA but may require more paperwork and fees. On the other hand, a self-directed IRA allows for greater diversification of assets while still providing tax benefits. Ultimately, which option is right for you will largely depend on your individual financial goals and risk tolerance level. For those looking to protect their wealth through precious metals investing with an IRA, understanding the differences between a solo 401k vs self-directed IRA can help ensure they make the best decision for their needs.


Is solo 401k better than IRA?

The answer to this question primarily depends on the individual investor's financial goals and needs. Generally speaking, a Solo 401k offers more flexibility than an IRA when it comes to investing in precious metals. With a Solo 401k, investors can contribute up to $57,000 annually (or $63,500 if over 50 years old) and have access to greater investment options, such as gold coins or bars that are not available with traditional IRAs. Additionally, there is no custodian involved with a Solo 401k, so all decisions are made by the account holder alone. Ultimately, both accounts offer tax-deferred growth potential, but whether one is better than the other will depend on each individual's unique situation.

Can you have a self-directed IRA and a solo 401k?

Yes, you can have both a self-directed IRA LLC and a solo 401k. A self-directed IRA allows investors to purchase alternative investments such as precious metals, real estate, private placements, and more. On the other hand, a solo 401k is an individual retirement account that offers high contribution limits and tax advantages for business owners without employees. Both of these accounts provide investors with opportunities to diversify their portfolios and safeguard their wealth through investing in precious metals.

What are the cons of a self-directed IRA?

Self-directed IRAs can be a great way to diversify your retirement portfolio, but there are some drawbacks that should be considered. First, they require more knowledge and expertise than traditional IRAs, so investors must do their due diligence before investing in order to ensure they understand the risks associated with each asset class. Second, self-directed retirement accounts may have higher fees and administrative costs compared to other types of retirement accounts. Finally, because these accounts involve alternative investments such as precious metals or real estate, it can be difficult for an investor to accurately value their holdings or liquidate them quickly if needed.

Are self-directed IRAs going away?

No, self-directed IRAs are not going away. They remain a popular way for investors to diversify their retirement portfolios and protect their wealth with precious metals investments. Self-directed IRAs allow investors to choose from a variety of investment options, including gold, silver, platinum, and palladium coins or bars held in an IRA account. These accounts provide tax advantages that can help grow retirement savings over time.

The Barron's Pick

Augusta Precious Metals is the most trusted gold IRA company